Michael Bracewell was the pick of the New Zealand bowlers, dismissing Zaman and Imam-ul-Haq, with Tim Southee and Glenn Phillips also taking a wicket each.
Earlier on Monday, the 19-year-old Naseem took his second five-wicket haul in international cricket to help Pakistan restrict New Zealand to 255 for nine after putting their opponents to bat at the National Stadium in Karachi.
Shah said, “A good performance is fun only when the team wins. Everyone bowled well. It was turning and I just bowled to my strengths.”